11 Top Places to Get the Best Pizza in Gatlinburg, TN

Finding the best pizza in Gatlinburg isn’t a difficult thing to do. With several choices, you can always sample each restaurant and decide which one you like best. We’ve compiled a list of 13 eateries that we think will give you a great start in finding the best pie you’ve ever had!

11 Great Places to Get the Best Pizza in Gatlinburg

1. Big Daddy’s Pizzeria

Looking for fresh sauce topped with fresh ingredients on hand-crafted dough? If so, Big Daddy’s Pizzeria is a joint you should try. The unique brick oven used in the restaurant uses a wood-fire flame for a delicious taste that you won’t experience anywhere else in town.

While checking out the best pizza in Gatlinburg, give their Wood Fire Roasted Wings a try too. Finish up dinner with their delicious Cannoli – a scrumptious Italian treat offered in three flavors.

Along with a downtown Gatlinburg location at 714 River Road, you can also check out Big Daddy’s in Pigeon Forge and Sevierville.

2. Ski Mountain Pizza

Bring your family, friends, or date to Ski Mountain Pizza and give their speciality pies a try. They offer a variety of pizza options as well as gluten-free choices to those that need them. A warm, friendly atmosphere makes this eatery a great choice for date night, a night out with friends, or a family dinner.

Along with pizza, Ski Mountain Pizza offers many other Italian options like calzones and pasta. Hoagies and gyros are also on the menu for those looking outside the Italian cuisine. After your meal, you will want to satisfy your sweet tooth with their Pineapple Upside Down or Lava Cakes!

Open until 1am every night at 631 Ski Mountain Rd, Ski Mountain Pizza is the perfect choice for a late night meal or snack.

Gatlinburg Pizza Places

3. Mellow Mushroom

Though Mellow Mushroom may be a franchise, we certainly cannot discount it having some of the best pizza in Gatlinburg! Each location is independently owned and operated, so you’ll get the same southern hospitality in this restaurant as you might get anywhere.

Mellow Mushroom is best known for their stone-baked pizzas and inventive topping offerings. Try the Meaty Mighty, Kosmic Karma, or create your own from the long list of toppings available.

Stop in at 903 Parkway in downtown Gatlinburg to give Mellow Mushroom a try.

4. Luigi’s Pizza

Located in the heart of downtown Gatlinburg since 2006, Luigi’s Pizza strives to use fresh ingredients to make the majority of their menu items from scratch. The owners manage a family farm nearby, and lots of their produce go into their pizza restaurant.

Luigi’s offers several pizza varieties or you can build your own with your favorite toppings. Their menu also boasts tasty appetizers, calzones, wings, and salads. Don’t forget to sample their dessert pizza, available in 3 flavors.

Stop in at 1017 Parkway for lunch and try the Luigi’s Pizza buffet available every day. If you prefer to eat later, you can dine in, get carry out, or even pizza delivery (within a 4 mile radius).

Related Reading: 13 Short & Easy Hikes in Gatlinburg

5. Smoky Mountain Brewery

You may not expect to see a location that doesn’t have “pizza” in the name. However, you don’t want to overlook the Smoky Mountain Brewery when you are seeking the best pizza places in Gatlinburg.

Relax after a fun day in the Smokies by turning up a micro-brewed beer and a tasty pie at this brewery. Try their unique offerings such as the T-Rex, Brewmaster, or Baker’s Choice. They also have burgers, subs and pasta if you are the odd man out in your crew.

Head to 1004 Parkway in Gatlinburg by midnight if you want to give Smoky Mountain Brewery a try.

Best Pizza in Smoky Mountains

6. Taste of Italy

Located in the Food City shopping center, Taste of Italy is a “hidden gem” most tourists may not consider. However, they offer some of the most quality pizza pies in the city.

With a variety of gourmet pizzas available here, Taste of Italy has something for everyone in your party. Sample the Philly Cheese Steak Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza, or the Chicken Pesto Pizza. You can always build your own if their combinations don’t strike your mood.

Located at 1235 E. Parkway in Gatlinburg, Taste of Italy touts themselves as being the city’s best kept secret. Make sure you give them a chance before you leave town!

7. Geno’s Pizza

Geno’s Pizza has been “baking pizza pies since ’75” and they have long been a local favorite in the Smoky Mountains. Not only are can they be found in Gatlinburg, there is a second location in Pigeon Forge if you decide to leave town for the day.

Serving only the freshest ingredients on their homemade dough, you can rest assured you are getting quality pizza in every single bite. Start with their famous cheese bread or wings before you move to one of their specialty pizzas, such as the Geno’s Special, BBQ Chicken & Bacon, or Extreme Pepperoni. Gluten free options are available as well.

A great family run business, Geno’s Pizza is located at 385 E. Parkway in Gatlinburg, and they offer carryout or delivery!

8. Big Bear Pizza & Subs

Another of the lesser known pizza joints in Gatlinburg is Big Bear, which many of the locals rave about. Fresh pizza, fast service, and many options – what more could you ask for when craving Italian for dinner?!

Big Bear’s menu is full of Italian cuisines. Pizza choices include Spicy Hawaiian, Bacon Cheeseburger, and Deluxe – this one is loaded with several toppings! They also offer hoagies, wings, salads, and sandwiches if anyone isn’t feel the pie.

Situated at 815 East Parkway in downtown Gatlinburg, Big Bear Pizza & Subs offers carryout or delivery. They open daily at 4pm for dinner or a late night meal!

9. Best Italian Cafe & Pizzeria

Best Italian has been serving locals high quality pies since 1976, and tourists that have found this “hidden gem” have raved about it as well. There are two locations in Gatlinburg, an express site for a quick bite downtown as well as a full restaurant if you want to enjoy their full authentic Italian menu.

Chow down on their signature pies, including Smoky Mountain BBQ, Kickin’ Chicken, and Pizza Bianca. They also offer calzones, pasta, seafood, and veal on their menu.

Hit up the express Best Italian Cafe location at 710 Parkway, or dine in at the restaurant in Elks Plaza at 968 Parkway. You can’t go wrong with either great place!

Pizza in Gatlinburg

10. Slice Pizza Bakery

Wanting authentic, New York-style pizza while staying in Gatlinburg? Look no further than Slice Pizza Bakery. Not only do they offer delicious pies, you can also grab a fresh salad or hearty calzone here.

Stop in the base of the Space Needle at 115 Historic Nature Trail to give Slice Pizza a try. You can just grab a jumbo-sized slice or get a pizza for the whole crew.

11. New York Pizza & Pasta

Tucked in the Mountain Mall on the Parkway, New York Pizza & Pasta is one of the best places to get your fill of Italian. Most tourists are pleasantly surprised to stumble upon this eatery in downtown and claim it’s great value for the whole family. 

For a quick lunch, grab a slice of cheese, veggie lovers, or meat lovers pizza. You can also grab a full pie if you are feeding a large group or want more for dinner. Don’t forget the garlic knots to start off the meal! A kids meal is also available if your little one doesn’t enjoy pizza. 

New Yark Pizza is situated at 611 Parkway, on Level B of the mall. It’s in a convenient spot to satisfy your taste buds and empty tummy!

Related Reading: 4 Best Gatlinburg Ghost Tours You Must Check Out

Final Thoughts

As you can see, delicious food can be found throughout the Smoky Mountains. Try one or more of the eateries on our list to satisfy your whole family with an easy meal while traveling through the area. Hopefully you’ll find the best pizza in Gatlinburg in one of more of our chosen restaurants!

Leave a Comment